Menu Back

Contact Back

Call Us Now!
Tap Here To Call Chat With Us!
Tap Here To Chat Send Us a Text/SMS
Contact Search Menu

Unnecessary Hysterectomy Malpractice

Approximately 600,000 hysterectomies are performed in the United States every year. Data suggests a hysterectomy may not be necessary in many situations. Are patients electing to have hysterectomy procedures? When is an unnecessary hysterectomy medical malpractice?

$35 Million Unnecessary Hysterectomy Verdict

In 2025, a jury awarded $35 million to a woman who underwent an unnecessary hysterectomy to remove cancer. This case involved a mixup of test results for a different patient who did have cancer. A biopsy from the actual patient showed no cancer. Still, the surgeon proceeded with a full hysterectomy.

The original test was performed by an outside lab, and a biopsy was performed by the surgeon. The surgeon could not explain why the lab test result found cancer when a physical biopsy did not. Instead, the surgeon advised the patient that immediate surgery was necessary.

Later, the patient discovered she was misdiagnosed, and the surgeon was aware that the tissue did not have cancer before the full hysterectomy was performed. This was the basis for a medical malpractice claim against the test testing lab, the surgeon, and the hospital.

Unnecessary Hysterectomy: Protecting Your Rights and Your Future

A hysterectomy is a life-altering surgery. When it is medically necessary – such as in the case of invasive cancer – it can be a lifesaver. However, studies suggest that a staggering number of hysterectomies performed in the U.S. are medically unnecessary.

unnecessary hysterectomy lawyer

If you underwent this procedure only to discover that alternatives were never discussed, or that your diagnosis was incorrect, you may be a victim of medical malpractice. At Haggerty Silverman & Justice, we help women hold negligent providers accountable for the financial, physical, and emotional toll of unnecessary hysterectomy procedures.

When is a Hysterectomy Considered “Unnecessary”?

While a hysterectomy can treat many conditions, it is often considered a “last resort.” A procedure may be deemed unnecessary if:

  • Alternatives existed: Your doctor failed to recommend less invasive treatments like medication, physical therapy, or a myomectomy (removal of fibroids only).
  • Misdiagnosis: The surgery was based on a faulty biopsy or an incorrect diagnosis of cancer.
  • Lack of Informed Consent: You were not fully briefed on the risks, side effects, or the permanent nature of the procedure.
  • Financial Gain or Convenience: The surgeon recommended the procedure because it was more profitable or easier for them than more complex, organ-sparing alternatives.

The Life-Altering Impact of the Procedure

We understand that the consequences of an unnecessary hysterectomy go far beyond the operating room. Victims often face:

  • Permanent Infertility: The loss of the ability to carry a child.
  • Surgical Complications: Injuries to the bladder or bowels, severe blood loss, or chronic infection.
  • Hormonal Shift: surgically induced early onset of menopause, leading to bone density loss and heart health concerns at an earlier age.
  • Emotional Trauma: Depression, anxiety, and a loss of “self” following an invasive and unwanted procedure.
hysterectomy medical malpractice

How We Build Your Malpractice Case

Medical malpractice cases are complex. To win, we must prove that your doctor deviated from the standard of care that another competent physician would have provided in the same situation. Our team works with medical experts to investigate:

  1. Your Medical Records: We look for evidence that your symptoms could have been managed without major surgery.
  2. Pathology Reports: We verify if the tissue removed actually showed the disease the doctor claimed was present.
  3. The Surgeon’s History: We investigate if the provider has a pattern of recommending aggressive surgeries over conservative care.

Note: Just because a surgery had a poor outcome doesn’t always mean it was malpractice. The law has specific requirements to qualify a claim for medical malpractice.

Take the Next Step

Contact the medical malpractice team at Haggerty Silverman & Justice to schedule a free review of your case. We will review your medical records and investigate any possible malpractice. You don’t pay us anything unless we recover money for you. Call 717-397-3200 or use our contact form to begin your free case evaluation today.

Frequently Asked Questions: Unnecessary Hysterectomy Lawsuits

1. How do I know if my hysterectomy was truly “unnecessary”?

Determining medical necessity often requires a deep dive into your medical records and pathology reports. Generally, if your doctor recommended a hysterectomy for a non-cancerous condition (like fibroids or heavy bleeding) without first attempting or discussing less invasive treatments – such as medication, hormonal therapy, or a myomectomy – the procedure may have been unnecessary. Our legal team works with medical experts to review your specific case and determine if the “standard of care” was met.

2. I signed a consent form before surgery. Does that mean I can’t sue?

No. Signing a consent form means you agreed to the risks of the procedure, but it does not give a doctor permission to be negligent. Furthermore, if your doctor failed to inform you of safer alternatives or based their recommendation on a misdiagnosis, your consent was not truly “informed.” You still have the right to seek justice.

3. What kind of compensation can I recover in a malpractice claim?

Every case is unique, but common damages in medical malpractice lawsuits include:

  • Medical Expenses: Coverage for the surgery itself and any corrective treatments or long-term care needed afterward.
  • Lost Wages: Compensation for time taken off work for recovery or due to long-term complications.
  • Pain and Suffering: For the physical pain and emotional distress caused by the surgery and its side effects.
  • Loss of Fertility: Significant compensation for the life-altering loss of the ability to have children.

4. How long do I have to file a lawsuit?

Every state has a statute of limitations, which is a deadline for filing a medical malpractice claim. This window often begins on the date of the surgery or the date you discovered the injury. Because these deadlines can be strictly enforced, it is vital to contact a lawyer as soon as you suspect something is wrong.

5. What if the surgery worked but I wasn’t told about other options?

Even if the surgery resolved your initial symptoms (like heavy bleeding), it may still be malpractice if a less invasive option could have achieved the same result with fewer risks. You have the right to preserve your organs whenever medically possible.

6. How much does it cost to hire a medical malpractice attorney?

At Haggerty Silverman & Justice, we work on a contingency fee basis. This means you pay nothing upfront. We only get paid if we successfully recover compensation for you. We take on the financial risk of investigating your case so you can focus on your recovery.