Case Study – Head-On Crash Caused By DUI Driver
Gary was driving a short distance from one family member’s house to a farm nearby. The distance was less than 3 miles, but Gary didn’t make it. A DUI driver hit Gary’s truck and sent him to the hospital. This is Gary’s story.
This story is a real case handled by the attorneys at Haggerty Silverman & Justice. The names and exact details of the situation have been changed to protect the identities of the parties involved. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Any pictures are for illustrative purposes only. Legal disclaimer.

Case Type: Vehicle Accident – DUI At-Fault Driver
Location: Pennsylvania
Date of Crash: Spring of 2025
Injuries: Traumatic brain injury (TBI), spinal injury with surgery, broken bones, etc.
Initial Offer From At-Fault Driver’s Insurance: $0
Final Settlement From At-Fault Driver’s Insurance: $50,000
Final Settlement From UM/UIM Coverage: $250,000
Total Final Coverage: $300,000
Date of Final Settlement: Summer of 2026
Attorney: Randall M. Justice
Horrific Crash
Gary woke up in an ambulance – that’s the only thing he remembers from this crash. He remembers waking up in an ambulance and the months of recovery afterward. He’s seen the pictures of his truck, the other guy’s vehicle, and he just can’t remember anything about the crash. Gary’s truck was totaled. The other driver’s vehicle was totaled.
Police Report of the Crash
The other driver told police he was driving home from an event when Gary’s vehicle crossed the yellow line and hit him head-on. But, the officer could smell the heavy odor of alcohol from the other driver. There were beer cans and a cooler thrown from the other driver’s vehicle. The officer also noted the driver’s story didn’t match up with what they were seeing at the crash scene. Not only was the other driver DUI, but he was trying to blame Gary for the crash!

DUI Charges
The other driver agreed to a field sobriety test, and failed. He was then taken for a blood draw test, which showed their BAC level at 0.2% – more than double the legal limit 2 hours after the crash. The driver was well over the legal limit at the time of the crash.
Accident Scene Investigation
There were no other witnesses to this crash. It was just Gary and the DUI driver. It was obvious to police that the DUI driver was lying about what happened. The police were able to figure out exactly what happened based on the evidence at the scene. The width of the tires and the skid marks at the scene told the truth about happened.
Here is what really happened. The DUI driver approached a bend in the road. He drifted off the right side of the road, over-corrected, and ended up in the oncoming lane. Gary had no time to react as the other driver came around the bend on the wrong side of the road, and hit him head-on.
Overcoming Limited Tort in PA
Gary’s car insurance coverage was limited tort. There are exceptions to overcome limited tort in Pennsylvania. In Gary’s situation, the crash caused significant injuries. The at-fault driver was also DUI. Additionally, the at-fault driver was licensed and registered in another state. Any of these circumstances alone are enough to overcome limited tort in Pennsylvania.
If you have limited tort coverage, you should consider changing to full tort. Drivers with limited tort coverage may be able to pursue a full tort claim in certain situations. Learn more about Pennsylvania limited tort car insurance.

Was This a Dram Shop Case?
We did our part to investigate all angles of this incident. The driver was DUI, which might qualify a dram shop case. Our investigation found the event the driver came from was BYOB. This means, the situation did not qualify as a dram shop case under Pennsylvania law. What is a dram shop injury lawsuit?
Injury Claim Against At-Fault Driver
While Gary recovered, we worked on his case. The at-fault driver had minimum insurance coverage, which wasn’t great for Gary. We were able to get the at-fault driver’s insurance to pay out the $50,000 policy limit 2 months after the crash. But, this did not cover all of Gary’s damages.
Uninsured/Underinsured Coverage
Gary had UM/UIM coverage on his car insurance – it was $250,000 in available coverage for Gary’s exact situation. The at-fault driver didn’t have enough insurance coverage to fully compensate Gary for his damages in this crash. We put together all the information for Gary’s insurance to pay him the full UM/UIM coverage.
Uninsured motorist / underinsured motorist coverage on your own policy can cover you in the event that the at-fault driver: a) has no insurance (uninsured), or, b) does not have enough insurance (underinsured) to properly compensate you for your injuries. If you do not have UM/UIM coverage on your insurance – add it today! Learn more about the importance of UM/UIM coverage.
Compensation After A Crash
In this case, we were able to get Gary all the insurance money that was available. In total, $300,000. But was it enough? This case highlights the importance of your own insurance coverage – don’t settle for state-minimum coverage! Without his own UM/UIM coverage, Gary would have only been eligible for the $50,000 from the at-fault driver’s insurance.
Vehicle Accident Injury Attorney
Despite his injuries, insurance didn’t pay Gary without a fight. Gary needed an experienced vehicle accident injury attorney to fight for all the money he deserved.
The team at Haggerty Silverman & Justice helped Gary, and we can help you. If you have been injured in a vehicle accident that wasn’t your fault, a reputable personal injury attorney may be able to help. Contact Haggerty Silverman & Justice for a free consultation. You don’t pay us anything unless we recover money for you.
